5 clones found

01BoroujPerlador

Perlador

by Borouj

● Top pickHigh match

~$35–60

02Montagne ParfumsCarlyle

Carlyle

by Montagne Parfums

High match

~$45

03Maison AlhambraCassius

Cassius

by Maison Alhambra

High match

~$20–30

04Ard Al ZaafaranTafakhar

Tafakhar

by Ard Al Zaafaran

Moderate match

~$17–25

05Dua FragrancesCumbria

Cumbria

by Dua Fragrances

Moderate match

~$35–45

Parfums de Marly's Carlisle is a highly acclaimed niche scent known for its deep, seductive profile of spicy nutmeg, crisp green apple, warm tonka bean, and a rich, dark base of vanilla, patchouli, and opoponax. The community clone landscape for Carlisle is very active, with several houses competing to capture its complex fruit-and-spice contrast and heavy, resinous drydown. Borouj Perlador is widely considered the highest-quality and most potent alternative, offering a deeper, luxury feel with a massive scent trail. For those seeking absolute accuracy and smoothness, Montagne Parfums Carlyle is celebrated for its oil-rich, highly accurate blend, while Maison Alhambra Cassius dominates as the most accessible and budget-friendly clone. Meanwhile, options like Ard Al Zaafaran Tafakhar and Dua Cumbria cater to varying preferences, offering lighter, cherry-inflected sweetness or a denser, heavier extrait experience.